The timing of the sacking of Brendan McCullum as England Test Head Coach makes no sense whatsoever.
The end of a humbling Ashes series over the winter, which England had lost 4-1 was surely the time to go. It would have given the powers that be in charge of making decisions six months to get a new hierarchy in place.
Instead Rob Key, McCullum and Ben Stokes all kept their jobs. While there were understandably concerns from many about this decision, given just how bad the Ashes were, there was some logic to the decision.
That logic being , that they would learn from the mistakes made and get better in the future.
Importantly Stokes and McCullum seemed very hungry to continue and right the wrongs of the past.
All of that has come crashing down in a matter of weeks. First Stokes resigned as Captain and retired from all forms of international cricket. And now, just a couple of weeks after, McCullum has been sacked as Coach.
The timing is completely baffling. While the Test series defeat to New Zealand was disappointing, it was hardly straightforward. After an impressive first Test victory, Stokes and Gus Atkinson were banned from the second Test for breaking a curfew. Ollie Robinson’s fragile body broke down again, and Jamie Smith missed it to attend the birth of his child.
With Stokes resigning the only real candidate to replace him long-term is Harry Brook who already captains the limited overs side. There has been some reluctance to promote him to the role given Brook’s own struggles off the field last winter.
But there is no doubt he’s impressing in the role. He has just led England to the top of the T20 World Rankings after thrashing India and has an impressive record of 16 wins from 22 matches.
Who has that been achieved alongside? McCullum. Instead of stability Brook will now have to build his new look side with a new coach, while still working with McCullum in the limited overs side of the game.
So where does this leave McCullum? At this stage it’s difficult to know. If his successor comes in and England sweep all before them, it perhaps places the former New Zealand captain in a difficult position. Equally the spectre of McCullum may not be helpful to whoever comes in to replace him.
Timing aside does McCullum deserve to lose his job? Again it’s very difficult to make a call here. On recent results it’s hard to argue against the decision. Circumstances notwithstanding England were hugely disappointing in the recent series against New Zealand. The Ashes was an absolute debacle, from their performances on it, to their preparation off it.
But it’s also worth remembering where the England Test side was when he took over. One win in 18 Test matches. He transformed the side immediately, taking away the fear, and giving them license to enjoy playing cricket again. It produced some indecisive results, and some thrilling Test match cricket, even when England weren’t always victorious. If he had his faults, and some would say there are many, but the main one is he is too one dimensional as a coach. He only knew one way to play. It may continue to serve him well as limited overs coach.
So Rob Key is the last man standing. Of all three I find it the most remarkable that he still finds himself in a job. I can’t see him hanging on for much longer.


