Somewhere in an alternate universe Manchester United are flying high near the top of the Premier League table. They beat Como in a topsy turvy game and then overcame Bournemouth to secure their place in the top four and firmly in the title race, even if they are still perhaps a little bit behind Manchester City and Arsenal.
This improvement in fortunes is led by local hero, Mason Greenwood, who is already approaching 150 goals for the club and just about to reach the peak years of his career.
That could have been how Mason Greenwood’s story played out, but for the events of 30th January 2022.
On that day Mason Greenwood’s life and plans came crashing down when his partner (and still current partner) Harriet Robson posted a number of photos and videos online which made very serious allegations of domestic abuse against Greenwood. We don’t know need to go into the details of those for this article other than to say that they were extremely graphic, disturbing and of the most serious nature.
The football world was quick to condemn Greenwood given the strength of the evidence and Manchester United rightly suspended him immediately, pending the outcome of the criminal investigation.
In October 2022, police charged Greenwood with attempted rape, assault occasioning actual bodily harm, and controlling and coercive behaviour.
However, in February 2023, over a year after Robson posted the videos and images on social media the charges were dropped. Police cited that there was no longer a realistic chance of conviction. They revealed the alleged victim had also asked for the police to drop their investigation.
The next six months passed with Manchester United remaining quiet while they carried out their own investigation. In mid August 2023, news began to leak that United were planning to reintegrate Greenwood into their first team plans.
However, the backlash to this news was extremely strong, with supporters groups, domestic violence organisations and even United’s own women’s team highlighting their significant concerns.
On 21st August United announced that Greenwood wouldn’t be brought back in to the squad. The statement included comments from both the club and Greenwood.
‘All those involved, including Mason, recognise the difficulties with him recommencing his career at Manchester United," said the club.
"It has therefore been mutually agreed that it would be most appropriate for him to do so away from Old Trafford, and we will now work with Mason to achieve that outcome.
"Based on the evidence available to us, we have concluded that the material posted online did not provide a full picture and that Mason did not commit the offences in respect of which he was originally charged. That said, as Mason publicly acknowledges today, he has made mistakes which he is taking responsibility for."
In a statement, Greenwood accepted he had "made mistakes" and took his "share of responsibility", but added: "I did not do the things I was accused of."
He said: "Today's decision has been part of a collaborative process between Manchester United, my family and me. The best decision for us all is for me to continue my football career away from Old Trafford, where my presence will not be a distraction for the club. I thank the club for their support since I joined aged seven. There will always be a part of me which is United.
"I am enormously grateful to my family and all my loved ones for their support, and it is now for me to repay the trust those around me have shown. I intend to be a better footballer, but most importantly a good father, a better person, and to use my talents in a positive way on and off the pitch."
The statement from United was woolly to say the least. Saying he did not do what he was accused of but also saying that Greenwood has made mistakes for which he was taking responsibility for.
So how do we explain the videos and images that were posted by Robson. Had they been edited in some way? If Greenwood wasn’t responsible for what he was accused of, then why not be clear about it.
Explain it to us. Perhaps then Greenwood would have a better chance to resume his career and the public would have a much clearer picture and be more able to make a judgement about the facts of the case.
The fact no explanation was forthcoming led me and many others to one conclusion. Greenwood did what he was accused of.
But the police gave up because they couldn’t make it stick given he was still in a relationship with his accuser.
From this point, Greenwood’s career resumed, firstly with a successful loan spell in Spain with Getafe, where he scored 10 goals in 36 games.
Two seasons at Marseille followed where he continued to impress. In two seasons he scored 48 goals in 81 matches.
He is now plying his trade for Fenerbahce in Turkey and has seven goals in 18 appearances so far this season.
Throughout the last four years, Greenwood has been consistently linked with some of Europe’s biggest clubs, with Barcelona and Athletico Madrid among those mentioned.
But none of those clubs have ever pulled the trigger. Perhaps there has been no truth to the rumours. But given his considerable talent I would expect that the clubs have at least considered signing Greenwood.
All of this begs the question. Has Greenwood not going to trial actually been bad for him in the long run? Should he have had his day in court? Establish the facts. Let the courts decide. If he’s found guilty, serve his time and then try and rebuild his life, and football career after.
The biggest issue that Greenwood and these clubs have is doubt. Nobody knows what truly happened. Which makes it impossible to take the risk.
On the flip side, I and many other observers, feel that Greenwood is extraordinarily fortunate to have a football career of any kind.
Ok, he may never play for the football clubs his talent alone deserves. But playing for the best teams in the world requires more than just talent on the pitch. It requires substance off it too.
Greenwood is being paid millions of pounds a year to play football. Lucky him.
Justice in football, is a murky area. When I wrote a Note on Substack about this article an Arsenal fan referenced the way they had handled the Thomas Partey case saying they felt they he should have been immediately suspended. But why should Partey, who has yet to be found guilty in a court of law, lose four years of his career while he waits for the verdict. Is that fair? What if he’s found innocent. He can’t get those four years back.
Do footballers, or anyone high profile for that matter, not deserve ‘innocent until proven guilty?’
Perhaps that’s where Greenwood falls short. He was never proven guilty or innocent. He simply exists somewhere in between, with most (this writer included) believing him to be guilty of his alleged crimes.
What about other footballers who have fallen short in the eyes of the law? Ched Evans was found guilty of rape, spent over two years in jail, maintained his innocence and eventually had his conviction overturned. At that point he was able to resume his football career.
Adam Johnson, formerly of Manchester City and England, never played professional football again after being found guilty of sexual activity with a child.
David Goodwillie never went to court for the rape he was accused off, but was found guilty in a civil trial brought by the victim. He then played for years for Cylde in the lower divisions of Scottish football. After scoring nearly a hundred goals, he signed for Raith Robers. The backlash against this move was swift but somewhat surprising. Why was it ok for Goodwillie to play for Clyde for years but then not for Raith Rovers? Even Clyde wouldn’t take him back when Raith Rovers decided they had made a mistake. He has spent the last few years playing in the ninth tier of Scottish football for Glasgow United. He maintains his innocence and will likely have his day in court in the next 12 months.
Their experiences jar with that of other players convicted of crimes. Former West Brom striker Lee Hughes, served four years in prison for causing death by dangerous driving. Upon release he resumed his career in the Football League, most notably for Notts County.
Luke McCormick killed two children in a car crash and yet resumed his football career on his release from prison, quietly retiring in 2022 after making 350 appearances with Plymouth Argyle.
I think the rise of the women’s game has played a huge part in ensuring that players like Johnson, Evans and Greenwood have found things so difficult. Women’s football is more popular than ever and I think that is shining a spotlight on crimes against women more than ever before. Should it have taken that? No. Is it a good thing? Absolutely. More girls than ever before are attending football matches, whether that be men’s or women’s football. As a parent myself it would be extraordinarily difficult to take my children to watch a player who has been convicted of a crime against a woman. What an appalling role model for my sons. And what message would that send to my daughter?
But are their crimes worse than Luke McCormick, who got behind the wheel of a car, drunk, and killed two small children?
I honestly don’t know. It’s a question that simply feels too big for me to answer.
Which begs the question. If a footballer is convicted of any crime, should it mean they are no longer allowed to be professional footballers? That they don’t deserve such privilege.
Possibly that is the answer. And it does feel like more and more clubs, particularly the ones at the very top, with huge commercial sponsors to appease are taking this approach.
Hence why I don’t think Mason Greenwood will ever play for one of Europe’s top clubs again.
But a huge part of society is allowing people to rehabilitate and make a positive contribution to society upon their release from prison.
Who are we to decide what job is suitable for such an offender?
‘Let them be a bin man,’ used to be the cry. But what an insult to bin men (or women) to suggest that this is a suitable job for a rapist or sex offender.
I’ll be honest. I’m not quite sure how to wrap this article up, other than to say I hope I’ve done the subject matter justice and not offended anyone with anything I’ve written. If I have it has truly been unintentional and I’m sorry for doing so.
It feels like footballers exist in a world where the normal rules simply don’t apply. If Mason Greenwood hadn’t been a footballer he would surely have been tried in a court of law for his crimes.
It’s a travesty that he wasn’t. Not just for society, but in my view, for him aswell. The court didn’t make their judgement but the people did. The fans of Manchester United did, along with so many others.
And for that at least, I think we can all be thankful.




Great, brave and honest article. Your question about resolved guilt vs unresolved suspicion is such a good one. Fair play for taking it on, really good read!
Really good handling of a very tricky subject, Aaron. You've handled that very sensitively.
From a female perspective, I think Greenwood represents what happens an awful lot in cases like this - there's often enough wiggle room for men to get out of it.
And the flip side is, there's enough doubt to fear ruining a man's life when he's innocent (not in this case, imo). And the law still sides with that. I'm not saying this doesn't happen btw - a whole other discussion.
The trouble with these types of crimes against women is proof and will to prosecute.
Killing someone is cut and dry (for the sake of argument). Rape and coercive control in domestic settings is much harder to deal with.
Good article, Aaron.